I really did mean politely, but I will be extra so. Or perhaps leave it at a bald statement of "Kinda wish you hadn't included so much spoiler detail for Atlantis Cranks." Don't want to get into an argument with her or anything, sticking up for you. She has a right to her opinion. :-)

But, I discover just now, there doesn't seem to be a comment function for that review blog or a way to contact the reviewer directly, so I'm left with dropping an email to the editor. I bcc'd you.